"STRAIGHTLACED: HOW GENDER GOT US ALL TIED UP"
Director: Debra Chasnoff
Trevor's Rating: 5 / 5 Stars
I have a confession: I broke down crying in the middle of this screening. This wonderful new feature documentary from Academy Award winning director Debra Chasnoff (from It's Elementary fame) features a variety of youth's perspectives on the impact of gender roles on men, women, and everyone in between.
Radical / separatist feminists have for far too long refused to incorporate an analysis of men's lives into their analysis and politics. Men, they would say, are studied in every other department on campus. Why give their lives any more attention than it already has? I believe that their brand of feminism ultimately ended up becoming the butt of jokes because of this refusal -- because men were made out to be the enemy, and because a feminist analysis gave men few tools to understand how their own gender impeded their ability to live life fully. Old school feminism made it seem like it was always easy to be a man and always difficult to be a woman. This was never true.
Straightlaced presents a new kind of analysis of gender that drops the insistence that it is women who only matter when we talk about gender. In this fabulous piece, we hear from all kinds of young people with a variety of gender presentations -- and a variety of racial and ethnic backgrounds (which, as we all know, work with gender to produce variations on similar themes). It takes young people's voices and experiences seriously, which is certainly where it draws its strength. It avoids jargon. It's matter of fact. And it's incredibly powerful.
As I mentioned at the start, I had a mini-breakdown halfway through the film when they tell the story of a flamboyant young boy who committed suicide. His friends and neighbors were interviewed while planting a memorial garden, and they had colorfully painted picnic tables with messages of tolerance and acceptance. When they panned to a table painted "Hate Free Zone" with a heart around it, the waterworks started coming. I couldn't hold back. The pain of growing up as a sissy boy in an intolerant culture flooded me with emotion. In different circumstances, would that have been my story?
The tears didn't stop there. Hearing so many young people speak openly and frankly about the way that gender restricts their actions, emotions, friendships, and sexualities kept my cheeks damp for most of the film. I can't recommend this film more -- particularly for educators who can use this film as a resource in the classroom. Once released on DVD, Groundspark (the film's producers) will I believe make available a set of classroom resources -- which would be a wonderful asset to educators.
This is 21st century feminism, folks. In fact, we need a new word for this kind of analysis. Feminism doesn't cut it. (Gender studies, perhaps, though it's a bit bland I think.) But whatever the terminology, this is the direction we need to moving in collectively as folks invested in reworking and expanding cultural constructions of gender and sexuality.
I am absolutely going to forward this to my academic mentor for Suffolk U., as it is right up her alley, as the Director of the Women and Gender Studies program; and I know she would love it.
It's a fascinating preview for sure, especially because it involves younger folk (not that I am much older), who grew up in a completely different environment thanks in part to stuff like the 2nd wave of feminism and the gay rights movement, and just good old fashion social progress.
One thing my feminist professors made clear is that when we defined a set of rules and standards for one sex, we inadvertently define the rules and standards for the other(s). It's partly why I consider myself a feminist. I'm completely with Bell Hooks, "feminism is for everybody."
As for what to call it, I've always fancied "Queer Studies" because to me it goes to the heart as to what it is about. Queer being the opposite of straight, focusing on the aspects of where we bend the norms of society and not confirm to rigid roles.
I say screw gender roles, we don't live in trees anymore where such rigid standards were necessary for survival.
But I really must insist that we get away from any idea of queer as being "the opposite" of straight. This kind of thinking is actually what I think is as the heart of the problem in Sexuality Studies today. "Queer" (in relation to "Queer theory") was invented in order to imagine the ways that a multitude of people with marginalized, illegitimate, illegal, and/or pathologized sexualities all challenge and potentially undermine normative systems of sexuality. In my mind, "queer" is in no way the opposite of straight. A "straight" man who gets fucked by his girlfriend with a strap-on is decidedly queer. A straight woman who is involved in commercial sex work is also queer, in my mind. Used in this way, "queer" is NOT an umbrella category for "LGBT" -- and using it as such just reinforces the kind binary gay/not-gay thinking that has stymied efforts to broaden the scope of sexuality studies in the past two decades.
I'm so pleased to see your positive review of this film!
In fact, I've been thoroughly enjoying all your running commentary on what you've seen at Frameline. For several years ago I was the Board Co-Chair for the Rochester Queer Film Festival, "ImageOUT." (Ironically, my co-chair at the time has now been the Executive Director of the Seattle Queer Film Fest which, you may remember, coincided with the recent Summit in Seattle...so I was able to see a few films there, as well.) Even though I'm not in a leadership role with our festival anymore, my hubby and I are members/supporters and avid film-goers....so I've loved your reviews because every year the Rochester festival includes a number of films that have screened @ Frameline...so you're giving me a fun sneak peek at what I might want or not want to see! Thanks!!
Anyhow, with regard to "Straightlaced" I'm really thrilled to read your thoughts/review. I haven't seen the entire film yet but I definitely know about it and am anxious to see it. I currently sit on the board of GLSEN here in Rochester and we decided just last month at our board meeting that we are going to purchase the DVD and accompanying curriculum for this film to augment the trainings and resources we provide to Rochester area schools around queer safety and access.
It's nice to see another voice for whom I have great respect reinforcing that was the right decision!! *smile*
About Us Trevorade is a community of people just like you who spend their days thinking about sex, gay men's health, and HIV/AIDS. Welcome!
We Need Your Support We're supported almost exclusively by donations from generous souls like yourself. So please, if you enjoy the content here, shell out a few gay dollars to help us cover our hosting bills.
Clips
N' Chips
Liberal-Minded. Antillean-American. Queer.
Non-PC Feminist.
Joe.
My. God.
Gay Culture, Short Stories, & More! NY-Based.
Kaleidoscope
Fellow Ann Arborite and
Gay Blogger. Sexuality & Human Rights focus.
Knucklecrack
Gay Activist Eric Levin's Fabulous NY-Based
Blog.
Pam's House Blend
She's a fabulous North Carolinian blogging about politics, LGBT and women's rights, the influence of the far Right, and race relations. What more can I say?
I am absolutely going to forward this to my academic mentor for Suffolk U., as it is right up her alley, as the Director of the Women and Gender Studies program; and I know she would love it.
It's a fascinating preview for sure, especially because it involves younger folk (not that I am much older), who grew up in a completely different environment thanks in part to stuff like the 2nd wave of feminism and the gay rights movement, and just good old fashion social progress.
One thing my feminist professors made clear is that when we defined a set of rules and standards for one sex, we inadvertently define the rules and standards for the other(s). It's partly why I consider myself a feminist. I'm completely with Bell Hooks, "feminism is for everybody."
As for what to call it, I've always fancied "Queer Studies" because to me it goes to the heart as to what it is about. Queer being the opposite of straight, focusing on the aspects of where we bend the norms of society and not confirm to rigid roles.
I say screw gender roles, we don't live in trees anymore where such rigid standards were necessary for survival.
Clarence --
Thanks for your thoughtful feedback!
But I really must insist that we get away from any idea of queer as being "the opposite" of straight. This kind of thinking is actually what I think is as the heart of the problem in Sexuality Studies today. "Queer" (in relation to "Queer theory") was invented in order to imagine the ways that a multitude of people with marginalized, illegitimate, illegal, and/or pathologized sexualities all challenge and potentially undermine normative systems of sexuality. In my mind, "queer" is in no way the opposite of straight. A "straight" man who gets fucked by his girlfriend with a strap-on is decidedly queer. A straight woman who is involved in commercial sex work is also queer, in my mind. Used in this way, "queer" is NOT an umbrella category for "LGBT" -- and using it as such just reinforces the kind binary gay/not-gay thinking that has stymied efforts to broaden the scope of sexuality studies in the past two decades.
xoxo
T
Trevor---
I'm so pleased to see your positive review of this film!
In fact, I've been thoroughly enjoying all your running commentary on what you've seen at Frameline. For several years ago I was the Board Co-Chair for the Rochester Queer Film Festival, "ImageOUT." (Ironically, my co-chair at the time has now been the Executive Director of the Seattle Queer Film Fest which, you may remember, coincided with the recent Summit in Seattle...so I was able to see a few films there, as well.) Even though I'm not in a leadership role with our festival anymore, my hubby and I are members/supporters and avid film-goers....so I've loved your reviews because every year the Rochester festival includes a number of films that have screened @ Frameline...so you're giving me a fun sneak peek at what I might want or not want to see! Thanks!!
Anyhow, with regard to "Straightlaced" I'm really thrilled to read your thoughts/review. I haven't seen the entire film yet but I definitely know about it and am anxious to see it. I currently sit on the board of GLSEN here in Rochester and we decided just last month at our board meeting that we are going to purchase the DVD and accompanying curriculum for this film to augment the trainings and resources we provide to Rochester area schools around queer safety and access.
It's nice to see another voice for whom I have great respect reinforcing that was the right decision!! *smile*