SOME BASIC TENETS
But these lofty goals aren't achieved automatically. This guide is in part about helping you navigate hookup websites to help you have great sex, but it's also about encouraging certain standards for communication that help foster a healthy and vibrant online sexual culture. I believe that a healthy sexual subculture must have at its core several basic tenets:
1. MUTUAL RESPECT: It's the golden rule, boys. Treat others the way you want to be treated. I think we need to strive to do this even in the face of hostility. Yes, that means taking a deep breathe and closing the window when someone sends you a nasty message. But it also means respecting people's last minute decisions to cancel the hookup you've had scheduled for a week. It's a tall order, but it will make cruising online a more pleasant and enjoyable experience.
2. HONESTY: I don't believe that gay men are liars - but a common complaint against hookup websites is that they are populated by dishonest people. For instance, people often feel compelled to give outlandish explanations for their failure to show up at your house as planned ("I got in a car accident on the way over") because they are afraid to say that they're scared or that they're just not that into the other person. As uncomfortable as it may be, I find it's much better to speak the truth rather than concoct fantastical reasons for not meeting up. If you're not into them, just (politely) say so.
3. JUDGMENT-FREE ATTITUDE: This is a bit of an extension of #1, but it's an important component. Let's just face it: People are different, and they may at times be turned on or excited by things that are baffling to you. That doesn't make them a "freak" (if anything, declaring a rather queer desire should be commended as an act of bravery). You might think that he shouldn't have taken his shirt off for his profile picture - or maybe you don't share his love for golden showers. But what you think of as a dealbreaker, others find incredibly sexy (and vice versa). If you're not into him or the kind of sex he's after, keep moving.
4. SEX-POSITIVITY: I can't tell you how many times I see men on Manhunt (a website built for men to find anonymous sex)who write in their profiles that they find hooking up to be immature, disgusting, and/or pathetic. In my book, that's not much different from the Christian Right shaming us for having sex with other men. Sex can be a wonderful thing, and we should celebrate that potential. What makes sense for you sexually may not make sense for others. Similarly, what works for you ten years ago may not work for you today. That doesn't mean that the way you structured your sex life ten years ago was necessarily immature or less worthy of our respect. Where there is consensual pleasure, there is something wonderful. Don't lose sight of that.
5. NO PRESSURE: I think this includes a number of different components. First, if someone says they are not interested in hooking up, don't pressure them into changing their mind. As someone who's both tried applying that tactic, and been on the recieving end of it, it does not work. If anything, it makes you appear desperate -- which is a major turn-off. Second, respect people's limits unless they ask you to push them. This means not biting their nipples if they say it hurts, but it also means respecting a potential trick's request to use condoms. It is not acceptable to pressure someone into having unprotected sex.
I'm sure there are more worthwhile principles I could list here, but these should prove to be a great start for fostering a healthy approach to hooking up online.
WHAT TO EXPECT
While it's commonly compared to an online marketplace for sex, hooking up online can often prove more challenging than buying groceries -- particularly for those of us living in smaller cities with fewer players. While you can certainly expect to find men to have sex with, don't expect for that to happen every time you log-in. Some people need to have a few conversations before they feel comfortable meeting in person, while others are only interested in meeting up immediately without much in the way of dialogue.
The Internet has been praised for its democratizing potential, and for its ability to erase difference through anonymity. But with the near-ubiquity of pictures in user profiles today, gay hookup websites often don't live up to these lofty goals. The typical rules of attraction that operate in real life tend to operate similarly online. Do not expect to suddenly step into an idyllic wonderland where anyone will agree to have sex with you if you just ask politely enough. You will be sorely dissapointed.
This doesn't mean that there aren't numerous exceptions of men whose preferences defy normative rules in gay culture about what kinds of men are supposed to be considered hot and which are not. Indeed, there are entire sexual subcultures dedicated to defying popular gay culture's normative tendencies about body size (e.g. bears), sexual practices (e.g. fisting, S&M), and intergenerational desire (e.g. Daddy/Boy relationships). More often than not, though, I think you'll find that users whose desires fall markedly outside the narrow boundaries of conformity will identify themselves.
Don't get me wrong: It never hurts to try, for sure. But those of us with extra meat in the middle shouldn't expect a muscled out gym bunny whose profile indicates they're only interested in other hard-bodied boys to like us for our personalities (though, again, they might - my experience just tells me that this isn't a probable outcome). It may sound harsh, but its just a good idea to approach hooking up realistically and not set our sights on the highly improbable. On the other hand, if that muscle boy contacts you and expresses interest, all bets are off.
Trevor, darling, sweetie, pet, this is going to hurt me more than it hurts you, okay maybe not, maybe you will call me another fine Celtic name, but this is not the right format for such an educational intervention. Who reads a guidebook about hookup sites?? My guess is they're more likely to read a blog or an agony uncle type column, and it has to be FUNNY...
You think so? I would have read it... I mean I feel you. But I don't know that's going to stop me from writing it... :)
While humor would certainly add to the readability of a guide to hooking up online, I think the general thrust of this draft is on point and deserves further development. Because hooking up is a stigmatized social practice, it's important to reflect on the reasons that make it all worthwhile, and to demonstrate that websites like Manhunt are capable of fostering relationships that are communicative, honest, pleasurable, and valuable.
I also think it would be useful to write a section on negotiating the line between hook-up and relationship. I have a history of turning casual rendezvous into relationships that are more serious, involved, and complicated than I really wanted in the first place. This could be avoided by being more forthright and assertive about my desire for a simply "in-the-moment," no pressure encounter.
Trevor,
Most of this has already been done. See the web site I created: dotMEN http://www.dotmen.net
It includes content on:
Thanks for the link, Michael! I've seen your wonderful site before. But as wonderful as it is, it's an AIDS website. And we know how people react to that. I want something totally unaffiliated with AIDS, that is clearly not related to public health. I also think there's something about online sexual ethics that I want to contribute. In short, this is much broader than what would be conceived of within a prevention framework.
I've been translating that first section into a wittier gayspeak at Daniel's suggestion. I wrote it in a rather dry tone at first because I wanted to take hooking up seriously and not rely on humor to make my point. But after some thinking it seems clear that we can still take it seriously with a few puns along the way. So I'm making it a bit less formal in language and a bit snazzier.
@ Scott: Yes I think that would be somewhere in a "Follow Up" section. That's a great idea, though. I was mostly concerned in that section about talking about how to keep in touch with tricks you like, but it makes sense to also add a bit about negotiating those ongoing relationships. Thanks!